GFX Honest ideas?

[._. 1.9k]

Hey, so I worked a little bit on this, and I feel that the stars don't quite match, and the tree looks really fake.

But, I'd like all of your honest opinions.

 

http://imgur.com/MQaTAjp

 

Pics used:

http://static.parade.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/Why-Do-Stars-All-Look-Almost-the-Same-Size-ftr.jpg

 

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-haApzah1xJQ/UcgWebn8StI/AAAAAAAAI8U/vHoleKA9DCY/s1600/big+tree++wallpapers+hd+%25285%2529.jpg

 

I would like your honest opinions, please, if it sucks, say it sucks, but explain why it sucks. If it's good, please explain why it's good. Thanks.

Updated October 6, 2015 by LPH

[Diversityy 32.4k]

I think the only thing that is bad is the white outline of the tree.

[Klepto 7.8k]

Here's what I'm thinking.

 

What you can try to do... Replace the sky that's in the tree picture, and simply replace it with the space picture. Then, make the tree and the ground slightly darker and see how that looks.

 

 

If you want to keep it how it is, just try making the tree slightly darker

[._. 1.9k]

Here's what I'm thinking.

 

What you can try to do... Replace the sky that's in the tree picture, and simply replace it with the space picture. Then, make the tree and the ground slightly darker and see how that looks.

 

 

If you want to keep it how it is, just try making the tree slightly darker

How do I replace the background? I've tried looking it up and I can't figure out how.

[Klepto 7.8k]

How do I replace the background? I've tried looking it up and I can't figure out how.

Just crop it out. With either the magic wand, or erase tool.

[Goggwell 18k]

How do I replace the background? I've tried looking it up and I can't figure out how.

Quick Selection is how I would do it, but you can also just use the Pen Tool for more precise selections

[Earthiest 1.1k]

Yeah like what they said above. Using the quick selection tool or the magic wand tool, to highlight the white background behind the tree and delete it. Or you can also look for a render of the tree which doesn't have a white background, so It'll be much more easy to apply it onto the background because you wouldn't need to remove any access things. After you'd do that just change the color by crushing the blacks, or however you feel it'll look better. Other than that, nice work!

Here's a tree without a background, if this helps.

 

 

 

[._. 1.9k]

Yeah like what they said above. Using the quick selection tool or the magic wand tool, to highlight the white background behind the tree and delete it. Or you can also look for a render of the tree which doesn't have a white background, so It'll be much more easy to apply it onto the background because you wouldn't need to remove any access things. After you'd do that just change the color by crushing the blacks, or however you feel it'll look better. Other than that, nice work!

Here's a tree without a background, if this helps.

Thanks for your help, but when I go to delete the background, nothing happens.

http://imgur.com/WTxmdGH

 

Also, when I do delete it, how do I add the background with the deleted background? Just add it as a layer?

[Earthiest 1.1k]

Thanks for your help, but when I go to delete the background, nothing happens.

http://imgur.com/WTxmdGH

 

Also, when I do delete it, how do I add the background with the deleted background? Just add it as a layer?

Once you delete the white background it'll just be transparent. But before you can edit an external image you have to rasterize the layer first.

[._. 1.9k]

Once you delete the white background it'll just be transparent. But before you can edit an external image you have to rasterize the layer first.

Nevermind.

Updated October 9, 2015 by LPH